Skip to main content

Athletes should go to SEA Games on merit

S. Navinraj qualified on merit to represent the country at the Myanmar SEA Games. However, the National Sports Council want to send Lee Hup Wei instead, reasoning that he should be given another chance because of his back injury.
S. Navinraj qualified on merit to represent the country at the Myanmar SEA Games. However, the National Sports Council want to send Lee Hup Wei instead, reasoning that he should be given another chance because of his back injury.

OUTSIDE interference is an ugly word. And, sadly, it has reared its ugly head again ā€“ this time in the selection of athletes to the Myanmar SEA Games in December.
The Malaysian Athletics Federation (MAF) have already selected their athletes for the Games and there was no place for two veterans with a glorious past ā€“ 400m hurdler Noraseela Khalid and high jumper Lee Hup Wei.

As the parent body governing athletics in the country, the MAF have the right to decide who gets to go and who doesnā€™t.
However, the National Sports Council (NSC) have seen it fit to meddle in the MAFā€™s selection process.

The MAF had done things the proper way ā€“ there was no favouritism and selection was based on current form.
Credit to the MAF for having set a high benchmark and for learning from their mistakes.
Every selection must be accounted for and there is no room for passengers, even if they happen to be Noraseela and Hup Wei.

Yes, these two have contributed so much in the past but the fact is they failed to beat the qualifying mark for the Games.
Noraseela, who turned 34 last month, underwent heel surgery in April and only resumed training last month.

She featured in the Malaysian Open on Oct 20 to try and qualify for the SEA Games.
But she failed dismally.
The 2011 Palembang gold medallist finished a disappointing fifth and last with a poor time of 61.54 in the meet. The SEA Games qualifying mark was 58.97.

Guess what NSC director general Datuk Seri Zolkples Embongā€™s reason was for wanting to send Noraseela to Myanmar? Because no Malaysian woman has qualified for the event.
Why do the NSC want send to an athlete, who is well past her prime, to the Games?
Then, there is Hup Wei.

The 25-year-old was among six high jumpers who qualified on merit for the Games.
Unfortunately, only two athletes from each country are allowed to feature in each event.
So, the MAF decided that only the top two finishers in the Malaysian Open would be selected for the Games.

Nauraj Singh Randhawa (2.20m) and S. Navinraj (2.15m) came up with the goods and were selected.
Three-time SEA Games gold medallist Hup Wei could only finish fourth with a height of 2.10m.
Guess what Zolkplesā€™ argument was in preferring Hup Wei to Navinraj?

ā€œHup Wei could have won the Malaysian Open if not for the back injury he suffered during the meet. Hup Wei should be given another chance to qualify for the Games by allowing him to compete in the Pahang Open on Nov 10 as entry by name is on Nov 15,ā€ said Zolkples.

MAF president Datuk Zainal Abidin Ahmad had made it clear that the Malaysian Open was the last meet for athletes to qualify for the Games.

Noraseela and Hup Wei knew it, and they blew it.
Why do the NSC want to undermine what the MAF had done?
Kudos to the MAF for sticking to their decision. They should not allow NSC to interfere with their selection criteria.

The NSC should just focus on what they are supposed to do ā€“ providing funds to the NSAs.
In other words, please mind you own business, NSC!



by Aftar Singh

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ex-coach's jail sentence cut to a year

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal yesterday sentenced former athletics coach C. Ramanathan to 12 months' jail for molesting two junior athletes 19 years ago. A three-man bench led by Datuk Mohd Hishamudin Mohd Yunus unanimously dismissed Ramanathan's appeal against conviction, but varied the jail sentence of four years to a year, which was to run concurrently. Following yesterday's ruling, Ramanathan, 75, a former teacher, walked out a free man as he had served 10 months in Kajang Prison. Convicts get one-third remission for good behaviour while in prison. However, he will lose his pension. Hishamudin, who sat with Datuk Abdul Wahab Patail and Datuk Linton Albert, said the court found no merit to overturn the conviction. "However, in reducing the sentence, we considered Ramanathan's age and the long years the appeal has taken." Deputy public prosecutor Awang Armadajaya Awang Mahmud submitted that then High Court judge Tan Sri Abdull Hamid E...

Govt Always Gives Emphasis To Sporting Culture, Says PM

KUALA TERENGGANU, May 29 (Bernama) -- Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badaw i said the government always gives emphasis on cultivating a strong sporting culture in achieving excellence at the international level. As such, the Prime Minister said, it was important to scout for young talents in sports. "I observe that the Malaysia Games (Sukma) has become one of the important platforms to do so. "In this arena, the potentials and skills of the youngsters can be identified for development so that they can achieve greater success in sports," he said in his message in the souvenir book of the 12th Sukma from May 31 until June 9. Abdullah said he was aware that competition in sports was very keen and challenging but this did not mean that Malaysian athletes were incapable of competing at the international level. "The fact is that we have all the characteristics required to be excellent. We must inculcate a strong fighting spirit so that we don't easily surrender,...

Indonesia Choose Komodo Dragon As SEA Games Mascot

KUALA LUMPUR, April 26 (Bernama) -- Host for the 26th SEA Games, Indonesia has chosen the Komodo dragon as mascot for the 2011 Games which will be held in Jakarta and Palembang from Nov 11 to 25. The Indonesia SEA Games Organizing Committee (Inasoc), was qouted by Jakarta Post as saying that a pair of Komodo dragons, a male (Modo) and a female (Modi), were chosen in recognition of the Republic's conservation efforts to protect the dwindling number of the rare lizard. Modo and Modi were unveiled last night at a function in Jakarta, to mark the 200-day countdown before the games open on Nov 11 in Palembang. The Komodo dragons, the largest lizard in the world, only live on the Indonesian islands of Komodo in Flores, East Nusa Tenggara. On Jan 15, Inasoc unveiled its logo, a Garuda eagle, to symbolize the power and grandeur of Indonesia. Indonesia dominated the Games between 1977, when it first competed, and 1997, failing to top the medal charts only twice in that p...